==+== CS 6301.007 Paper Review Form ==+== DO NOT CHANGE LINES THAT START WITH "==+==" UNLESS DIRECTED! ==+== ===================================================================== ==-== Your Name: (Your name here) ==-== Net ID: (Your Net ID here) ==-== Title: (Paper title here) ==+== A. Overall merit ==+== Choices: 1. Strong reject - clearly unsuitable ==+== 2. Reject - will argue against ==+== 3. Weak reject - will not argue against ==+== 4. Weak accept - will not argue for ==+== 5. Accept - will argue for ==+== 6. Strong accept - clear accept ==+== Enter the number of your choice: (Your choice here) ==+== B. Reviewer expertise ==+== Choices: 1. No familiarity ==+== 2. Some familiarity ==+== 3. Knowledgeable ==+== 4. Expert ==+== Enter the number of your choice: (Your choice here) ==+== C. Paper summary (One paragraph summary of the paper here) ==+== D. Paper strengths + (Brief description of a strength) + (Brief description of a strength) + (Brief description of a strength) ==+== E. Paper weaknesses - (Brief description of a weakness) - (Brief description of a weakness) - (Brief description of a weakness) ==+== F. Comments for authors (Details of the strengths and weaknesses here; e.g., one short paragraph per strength/weakness; try to include suggestions for improvement) ==+== End Review